Antidepressants (Overuse)

On the 9th May 2018 Michelle Ballantyne, MSP, raised the important issue of antidepressant overuse in the Scottish Parliament:

This was the first part of the response made by the Minister for Mental Health:

As an NHS doctor who has worked as a psychiatrist  in Scotland for over 25 years I am not reassured by this response by the Minister for Mental Health. I have highlighted three aspects of this response which I wish to briefly consider:

I agree that prescribing should follow the principles of  informed consent and shared decision making.  However informed consent will not be possible if the information that doctors base prescribing on follows marketing and promotion rather than independent, and more objective, continuing medical education.  The Scottish Government has consulted the public on the need for mandatory declarations of financial competing interests for doctors and academics in an open, central register. The public made it clear that this was what they felt was necessary. More than two years on from this consultation and there is no such system ensuring the transparency that is necessary for informed decision making between clinician and patient.

Where is the “good evidence” to support the prescribing of antidepressants to 1 in 7 Scots, a significant proportion of whom are taking antidepressants long term or indefinitely? I have, like others, asked the Scottish Government to provide this “good evidence” but have been provided with no evidence to support such mass prescribing of  long term antidepressants.

Currently there is a petition being considered by the Scottish Parliament in relation to potential problems with prescribed medications. This has highlighted that an important aspect which should determine the “appropriateness” of prescribing, namely the experience of people who are taking medications, has not been given the weight that it should.


2 Replies to “Antidepressants (Overuse)”

  1. Excellent comments Michelle. The Scottish Parliament just like the English Parliament have been guilty for decades, in pushing the issue of long term prescribing of both SSRIs and Benzodiazepines ( tranquillisers ) into the long grass, and ignoring hard evidence by patients of the harm and dependence forming nature of these mind altering drugs. This national scandal is compounded by the near complete lack of NHS safe, dedicated withdrawal services to help those patients brave enough to withdraw from their iatrogenic dependence. Professor Malcolm Lader a world expert on benzodiazepines eg ( Diazepam ) is on public record as saying ” Benzodiazepines are harder to withdraw from than heroin “. So where are the NHS services to help the innocent prescribed victims of these drugs, who only took their medication as prescribed by their doctor ?

  2. Pingback: 1 in 7 | P.A.S.T.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.