Hole Ousia is beyond measurement.
Lennox and Gotthelf, in “Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology”:
Hans-Georg Gadamer, in “The Enigma of Health” :
In a poetic form by Peter J. Gordon:
This was a kind of experimental film where I combined an old audio track (narrator and choir) with some of John Berger’s words from “Here is where we meet”. I was perhaps trying to follow John Berger’s statement that he “risks to write nonsense these days”
The audio track is from this film by me: Oor auldest relative (made 2 years ago)
The words are by John Berger from “Here is where we meet” (just recently read by Peter)
This was filmed at Stirling castle in the old cemetery and features the Martyrs monuments.
So what might this film be about? Well I have no religious faith so it is not about that. Perhaps it is about learning over time? Perhaps it is about the meeting of Philosophy with Science? Perhaps it is about wounds and how we react to them? Perhaps it is about how poetry can convey briefly what other disciplines of thought may struggle with? Or perhaps it is about all of these and more? Though, rest assured this film does not offer an overall Philosophy!
This film takes as its title the opening section of the British Medical Journal of the last century.
The idea behind this film is to question what may be considered as “medical literature”?
I have deliberately placed myself at the centre of this film. What may appear as “monomania” is quite deliberate! I don’t know about you, but I read for pleasure and also because it gives me access to the lives of others. Literature opens up new worlds for me.
In this film I surround myself with some of those authors I have enjoyed reading and who have helped me to grow as a person and as a doctor.
We must remember that we are all subjective. We cannot put ourselves into the minds of others and truly share their lived experience.
This film also suggests, by including reference to the “modern ruin” St Peter’s Seminary in Cardross, (built in 1967, the year I was born) that we pass through time and that we age. I have included consideration of passing time as literature reminds us that medical science cannot ignore this.
In short this film is an artistic expression of the so-called “two cultures”.
Music credit: Spem in alium – Thomas Tallis
(1) The Pineapple, Dunmore
(2) Mossgrove, Bridge of Allan
(3) Old Stirling Bridge
Authors whose words have featured in my films.
The wonderful and genial doctor and poet, Femi Oyebode.
This is actually a film that has several layers. It is quite a philosophical film about how technology – “the scientific revolution” – may have made us all rush too much. In the process of rushing we risk losing the light: enlightenment. This being learning through communities of minds over many centuries (such as the humanities)
A film about the inspiring doctor and poet, Femi Oyebode: