“Bonuses for senior doctors rise”

It was reported this week that “bonuses for senior doctors” in NHS Scotland is on “the rise”:Discretionary points4This reminded me of a range of views expressed after I offered my personal considerations about “pay awards” for NHS Consultants.

I should say that I found the ‘award panel’ to be thorough but hugely labour intensive in terms of time and resource. “Cost” should perhaps be considered a number of ways:discretionary-points1 This was one replyDiscretionary points2 This was another:Discretionary points3 This week’s report began:Discretionary points5 Consultants can get up to seven “discretionary points” before moving on to three levels of “merit awards”:Discretionary points6 Discretionary points7 Discretionary points8Discretionary points9My personal view is that such financial incentivisation risks skewing behaviour. This potential has been evidenced in other areas of healthcare where “incentivisation” has been involved.

There may be further consequences of financial incentivisation: such that professionalism may be “guided” more by managers, politicians and “improvement science” than by experience, training and knowledge.Discretionary points9cIt is many years since I was part of a discretionary award panel but I noted at the time that a number of applicants were working “jointly” with the pharmaceutical industry, particularly in research. Such research would significantly improve the chance of a senior doctor getting discretionary points or merit awards. None of these senior doctors did I ever find declaring such interests on any register of any sort.

I noticed one reply to this recent article commented that:Discretionary points9d We must also consider that:Discretionary points9eHere are the criteria for Discretionary points as part of any annual application: Discretionary-points9b

Declaration: I have one discretionary point. I no longer apply for awards. This is my personal view. I respect all other views.

Historical note: Additional payment to consultants dates back 
to 1948 when "incentive payments" were available to encourage 
consultants to join the NHS. The "merit award" system was 
nationally based and has progressed to the present mixed local 
and national awards system.

One thought on ““Bonuses for senior doctors rise”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s